A square photo or a cartoon with white capital text in a thick black outline at the top and the bottom. The Impact typeface and the format spread on forums and 4chan from 2006.
Core thesis
Make the caption the picture: one setup line on top, one punch line below, in a font that stays legible at any size.
Design principles
Set text in Impact or an open look-alike (Anton, Oswald 700) in white capitals.
Add a black outline of 3px to 4px per 40px of text, drawn outside the glyph.
Place the setup line at the top and the punch line at the bottom, each 5% to 8% from the edge.
Size the text so that each line spans 80% to 95% of the width; break to a second line at 24 characters.
Crop the picture to a square or to 4:3 and let it fill the whole canvas.
Use a picture with an obvious face or pose; no logo, no border, no extra graphics.
Keep the captions short: 3 to 8 words in each line.