An image with an odd crop, a strange cut-out or a calm, odd caption that has no clear punch line. It grew from Facebook groups and Reddit in 2016 and often breaks the old image-macro rules on purpose.
Core thesis
Drop the joke structure: let a strange picture and a calm caption make a mood with no answer.
Design principles
Compose 2 to 4 layers: a flat or photographic ground, a cut-out figure and one odd object.
Use a calm caption of 1 to 6 words in a plain sans-serif at 24px to 36px, off the usual top and bottom positions.
Place the cut-out with a 1px to 2px visible rough edge, scaled 20% to 400% out of true size.
Use a limited, odd colour pair: a flat teal (#2E9C9A) and a dull orange (#E08A3C) on grey.
Add a 3% to 8% grain and one soft glow, with no clean grading.
Leave 30% to 50% of the canvas empty, so that the odd object has air.
Repeat one object or name across a series to build a private joke.